Business Daily Media

No point complaining about it, Australia will face carbon levies unless it changes course

Reports that Britain’s prime minister Boris Johnson is considering calling for carbon border levies[1] at the G7 summit to be held in London in June have produced a predictable reaction from the Australian government.

The levies would impose tariffs on carbon-intensive goods from countries such as Australia that haven’t adopted a carbon price or a 2050 net-zero emissions target.

Appearing to be shocked by the news, Energy Minister Angus Taylor declared that Australia is “dead against[2]” carbon tariffs.

They were a “new form of protectionism designed to shield local industries from free trade”.

In fact they are already the policy of the European Union[3] and the US, where President Joe Biden[4] calls them a “carbon adjustment fee against countries that are failing to meet their climate and environmental obligations”. Canada[5], which has an economy-wide price on carbon, isn’t worried.

Saying you’re dead against[6] something doesn’t stop it, and nor does asserting that it is anti free trade, when it is just as arguable that it is pro fair trade because it denies exporters from countries that aren’t taking action against climate change an unfair advantage.

Australia not the primary target

The mining industry itself made this point during the Gillard government’s introduction of Australia’s short-lived carbon price.

It would leave Australian exporters at a “disadvantage compared with international competitors[7]”.

Australia isn’t the primary target in any event. The main aim of carbon tariffs would be to encourage China’s leader Xi Jinping to shift his country’s zero emissions date from 2060 to 2050[8], benefiting the rest of the world.

Read more: Vital Signs: a global carbon price could soon be a reality – Australia should prepare[9]

If Xi Jinping does it, he’ll be on a level playing field with much of the world, although not with Australia, whose fate, like that of Britain’s Admiral Byng in 1757 would be used “to encourage the others[10]”.

Complaining won’t much help. The International Monetary Fund[11] has endorsed[12] the idea, saying

in the absence of an agreement on carbon pricing – which would be by far preferable – applying the same carbon prices on the same products irrespective of where they are produced could help avoid shifting emissions out of the EU to countries with different standards

The World Trade Organisation, which has in the past has pushed back[13] against environmental considerations in trade, is neutered.

World Trade Organisation powerless

In the late 1990s the WTO struck down a range of environmental restrictions imposed by the United States that required imported tuna to be labelled “dolphin safe[14]” and required shrimp catchers to take action to protect turtles.

These decisions proved disastrous for the WTO, producing bitter hostility from the environmental movement and contributing to mass protests at the 1999 WTO meeting, which became known as the Battle of Seattle[15] and ultimately killed the Doha round of trade negotiations[16].

Right now the WTO is in the organisational equivalent of an induced coma. By refusing to fill vacancies as they arose, the Trump Administration denied its appellate panel a quorum, forcing it to stop hearing cases[17].

No point complaining about it, Australia will face carbon levies unless it changes course President Donald Trump, neutered the World Trade Organisation. AP

The result is that any appeal to the WTO against carbon border tariffs would be left in limbo. US President Joe Biden has agreed to the appointment of a new WTO director general, stalled by Trump, but is in no hurry to re-establish the appellate body.

Instead, he will first try to refashion the WTO into an organisation that supports his own policies, among them stronger environmental measures, carbon tariffs and “Buy American” provisions. When reformed, the appellate body will give complaints from Australia’s government short shrift.

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has shown some signs of recognising these realities, making baby steps[18] towards announcing a 2050 zero emissions target.

But time is short. Morrison will have to either face down the denialists and do-nothingists[19] on his own side of politics, or set himself, and Australia, up for a series of humiliations on the international stage, with real and damaging consequences.

References

  1. ^ carbon border levies (www.bloomberg.com)
  2. ^ dead against (www.smh.com.au)
  3. ^ European Union (www.bloomberg.com)
  4. ^ Joe Biden (joebiden.com)
  5. ^ Canada (www.journalpioneer.com)
  6. ^ dead against (www.theguardian.com)
  7. ^ disadvantage compared with international competitors (www.theaustralian.com.au)
  8. ^ 2060 to 2050 (www.vox.com)
  9. ^ Vital Signs: a global carbon price could soon be a reality – Australia should prepare (theconversation.com)
  10. ^ to encourage the others (militaryhistorynow.com)
  11. ^ International Monetary Fund (www.climatechangenews.com)
  12. ^ endorsed (www.imf.org)
  13. ^ pushed back (openknowledge.worldbank.org)
  14. ^ dolphin safe (www.wto.org)
  15. ^ Battle of Seattle (www.britannica.com)
  16. ^ Doha round of trade negotiations (www.theguardian.com)
  17. ^ stop hearing cases (theconversation.com)
  18. ^ baby steps (theconversation.com)
  19. ^ denialists and do-nothingists (www.nytimes.com)

Authors: John Quiggin, Professor, School of Economics, The University of Queensland

Read more https://theconversation.com/no-point-complaining-about-it-australia-will-face-carbon-levies-unless-it-changes-course-155200

Business Daily Media Business Development

How Microsoft's Activision Blizzard takeover will drive metaverse gaming into the mass market

Ready Player 1,000,000,0001?Sergey NivensMicrosoft was positioning itself as one of the pioneers of the metaverse even before its US$75 billion deal to buy online gaming giant Activision Bli...

Theo Tzanidis, Senior Lecturer in Digital Marketing, University of the West of Scotland - avatar Theo Tzanidis, Senior Lecturer in Digital Marketing, University of the West of Scotland

Some of the super-rich want to pay more tax – but society cannot afford to depend on them

Shutterstock/PilgujDemands for the super wealthy to pay more taxes are not new. But they don’t usually come from billionaires or millionaires.Yet on January 19 2022, around 100 of the ...

Peter Bloom, Professor of Management, University of Essex - avatar Peter Bloom, Professor of Management, University of Essex

A killer app for the metaverse? Fill it with AI avatars of ourselves – so we don't need to go there

Ready avatar one?Athitat ShinagowinBig numbers coming. Microsoft’s US$75 billion (£55 billion) acquisition of Activision Blizzard has landed – true to Call of Duty vernacul...

Alex Connock, Fellow at Said Business School, University of Oxford, University of Oxford - avatar Alex Connock, Fellow at Said Business School, University of Oxford, University of Oxford

Labelling Equipment; Prayers Have Been Heard and, Answered

If you are an instrumental part of a management team for a business that now requires labels for their products or goods, then traditionally you’d have had one of three choices, if the...

Business Daily Media - avatar Business Daily Media

Leading Australian Microsoft partner Satalyst acquired by Canon

Satalyst, one of the leading Microsoft cloud and security partners in Australia, has today announced that effective immediately it has been acquired by Canon Australia. Satalyst will joi...

Business Daily Media - avatar Business Daily Media

How Timeline Maker Helps Business Owners On Their Targets

With many businesses today, the challenge is to make the audience know what you are all about. You can never go wrong with a website or an online presence for it is one of the most effecti...

Business Daily Media - avatar Business Daily Media



NewsServices.com

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion