Business Daily Media

Big Tobacco's decisive defeat on plain packaging laws won't stop its war against public health

  • Written by Genevieve Wilkinson, Lecturer in Intellectual Property and Human Rights, University of Technology Sydney

After a decade of legal challenges by the tobacco lobby, Australia’s pioneering push to eliminate all tobacco advertising finally has clear air.

Its longest stoush, over plain packaging laws introduced in 2012, finally ended last month, when the highest adjudicative body of the Word Trade Organisation affirmed a 2018 ruling the laws did not constitute an effective trade barrier or infringe tobacco companies’ trade mark rights.

This is a significant win. But the global war is far from over. While this decision should encourage more countries to introduce plain packaging, the tobacco lobby can still be expected to use legal chicanery to thwart such public health measures.

Read more: Australia's decisive win on plain packaging paves way for other countries to follow suit[1]

Eliminating tobacco advertising

Big Tobacco's decisive defeat on plain packaging laws won't stop its war against public health Australian rugby league’s Winfield Cup, awarded to grand final winners from 1982 to 1995. Winfield’s use of the sport to promote its products ended with federal laws prohibiting such advertising. National Library of Australia

Australia’s tobacco plain packaging laws were a world first – the final step in a national preventative health strategy[2] to deter smoking by eliminating all avenues for tobacco promotion.

It followed Australia banning cigarette advertising on radio and television in 1976, banning the broadcast or publication of any form of tobacco promotion (such as through sponsorship of sports) in 1993[3], requirements for text-only health warnings on tobacco products in 1995, and warnings featuring graphic images of smoking health impacts in 2006.

Branding on packaging was seen as the last avenue for tobacco companies to market their products to smokers.

The plain packaging laws banned all distinctive branding elements on packets. All products had to use the same drab brown colour found by research to be the least appealing[4].

Only “word marks” identifying the source and type of tobacco product, such as Marlboro Gold or Champion Ruby, were permitted.

Big Tobacco's decisive defeat on plain packaging laws won't stop its war against public health Australia’s uniform tobacco plain packaging, introduced in 2012. Lukas Coch/AAP

Legal challenges to Australia’s law

The tobacco lobby sought to thwart the Australian law through a variety of legal challenges.

British American Tobacco and Japan Tobacco International took action in Australia’s High Court. They argued the law was an unconstitutional acquisition of their intellectual property rights in their brands. The High Court conclusively rejected this in October 2012[5].

Phillip Morris reorganised its legal structure to seek compensation as a Hong Kong company under provisions of the 1993 Investment Promotion and Protection Agreement between Australia and Hong Kong. This gambit failed in 2015[6].

The WTO case was initiated in 2013 by tobacco exporters Cuba, the Dominican Republic, Honduras, Indonesia and the Ukraine, with tobacco industry help[7]. They argued Australia had restricted trade and trade mark use more than needed to protect public health, contravening international trade rules.

The WTO rejected these arguments in 2018. Its Appellate Body affirmed that decision on June 9, rejecting the appeal by Honduras and the Dominican Republic.

Read more: Coronavirus: big tobacco sees an opportunity in the pandemic[8]

Trade mark arguments

The Appellate Body ruled plain packaging was a legitimate part of Australia’s comprehensive range of tobacco control measures and did not amount to a restriction on trade[9].

It rejected the argument Australia had infringed trade mark rights under the 1995 Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (known as TRIPS), binding on all 164 WTO member nations.

It affirmed TRIPS granted a trade mark owner “the exclusive right to preclude unauthorised third parties from using identical or similar signs”. But it said there was no “positive right” to use a trade mark, as the appellants argued.

Nor did plain packaging laws contravene section 20 of the TRIPS rules[10], which states trade mark use “shall not be unjustifiably encumbered by special requirements”. Member nations “enjoy a certain degree of discretion in imposing encumbrances on the use of trademarks”, the Appellate Body said.

It agreed Australia’s policy was supported by the public health objectives and evidence, including a 2016 review[11] showing reduced smoking rates.

Impact of plain packaging on smoking prevalence in Australia

Big Tobacco's decisive defeat on plain packaging laws won't stop its war against public health Study of the impact of the tobacco plain packaging measure on smoking prevalence in Australia. 2016. Tasneem Chipty/Roy Morgan, CC BY-SA[12][13]

It also noted Australia’s obligations to reduce smoking as a signatory to the World Health Organisation’s 2003 Framework Convention on Tobacco Control[14]. The convention’s guidelines[15] recommend “measures to restrict or prohibit the use of logos, colours, brand images or promotional information on packaging”.

Global battle will continue

So this is a comprehensive vindication of Australia’s leadership on tobacco packaging. It should encourage other nations to follow suit. More than ten have already done so. The latest is Singapore, where plain packaging laws came into effect on July 1[16].

But don’t expect Big Tobacco to stop using litigation and other tactics to deter nations following suit.

Defending Phillip Morris’ Hong Kong gambit, for example, cost Australia about A$50 million[17] in legal fees. Researchers have suggested the threat of legal action using trade deals delayed New Zealand’s introduction[18] of tobacco plain packaging laws by years.

For poorer nations such costs are an even greater deterrent. Uruguay, for example, won its six-year plain-packaging battle with Phillip Morris[19] only with aid from US billionaire Michael Bloomberg.

Read more: China's tobacco industry is building schools and no one is watching[20]

Big Tobacco's decisive defeat on plain packaging laws won't stop its war against public health Ferrari teammates Fernando Alonso and Felipe Massa at the Australian Formula 1 Grand Prix in Melbourne, Australia, in March 2010. The racing team was accused of using ‘subliminal’ tobacco advertising for the Marlboro brand in exchange for a US$1 billion sponsorship deal. Diego Azubel/EPA

Tobacco companies also have a history of using other means to get their way. In South Africa in 2017, for example, British American Tobacco threatened to close[21] its local cigarette factory if the government pursued plain packaging laws.

Read more: The next battles against tobacco must be fought in the world’s major cities[22]

With about 80% of the world’s 1.3 billion smokers[23] living in low and middle income countries, we can expect tobacco interests to rely on their financial might, if not their legal right, to defend their profits.

Their war against the human right to health[24] will continue.

References

  1. ^ Australia's decisive win on plain packaging paves way for other countries to follow suit (theconversation.com)
  2. ^ preventative health strategy (extranet.who.int)
  3. ^ in 1993 (www1.health.gov.au)
  4. ^ the least appealing (www.independent.co.uk)
  5. ^ in October 2012 (theconversation.com)
  6. ^ failed in 2015 (www.theguardian.com)
  7. ^ tobacco industry help (www.reuters.com)
  8. ^ Coronavirus: big tobacco sees an opportunity in the pandemic (theconversation.com)
  9. ^ restriction on trade (www.wto.org)
  10. ^ section 20 of the TRIPS rules (www.wto.org)
  11. ^ including a 2016 review (www.health.gov.au)
  12. ^ Tasneem Chipty/Roy Morgan (www.health.gov.au)
  13. ^ CC BY-SA (creativecommons.org)
  14. ^ Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (www.who.int)
  15. ^ guidelines (www.who.int)
  16. ^ on July 1 (tobaccoreporter.com)
  17. ^ about A$50 million (theconversation.com)
  18. ^ delayed New Zealand’s introduction (global-uploads.webflow.com)
  19. ^ battle with Phillip Morris (theconversation.com)
  20. ^ China's tobacco industry is building schools and no one is watching (theconversation.com)
  21. ^ threatened to close (www.iol.co.za)
  22. ^ The next battles against tobacco must be fought in the world’s major cities (theconversation.com)
  23. ^ 80% of the world’s 1.3 billion smokers (www.who.int)
  24. ^ human right to health (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)

Authors: Genevieve Wilkinson, Lecturer in Intellectual Property and Human Rights, University of Technology Sydney

Read more https://theconversation.com/big-tobaccos-decisive-defeat-on-plain-packaging-laws-wont-stop-its-war-against-public-health-140439

Business Today

3 in 4 fundraisers have experienced sexual harassment on the job – often because of inappropriate behavior from donors

Sexual harassment is a common workplace hazard for nonprofit fundraisers.fizkes/iStock/Getty Images PlusWhile the #MeToo movement that raised public awareness of sexual harassment is making fewer headlines than it did in 2017 and ...

Cathay Pacific 2021 Sustainability Report

New commitments in carbon neutrality and diversity, and supporting the Hong Kong community during the pandemicThe Cathay Pacific Group has released its annual Sustainable Development Report that addresses its commitment and prog...

Cozycozy, is tackling consumer manipulation in the travel industry

With its user-centric algorithm, Cozycozy fights against the Online Travel Agencies' rampant manipulation of consumers’ choices. In 2019, 112.3 million domestic trips and 11.3 Million international trips were taken by Austral...

Foreign companies exiting Russia echo the pressure campaign against South Africa's racist apartheid system

McDonald's is leaving Russia after three decades of operating there.Sefa Karacan/Anadolu Agency via Getty ImagesMcDonald’s provided many Russians with their first taste of capitalism three decades ago. Now, the global fast-f...

Jennifer Westacott's interview with Ross Greenwood

Ross Greenwood, host, Business Now: Joining us is the chief executive of the Business Council of Australia, Jennifer Westacott. Jennifer, many thanks for your time as always. Quite clearly the government is setting out its age...

Business success as Aussie kids skateboard brand, Ookkie, launches in UK and Europe

Australia’s leading kids skateboard company, Ookkie, has set the wheels in motion for global business success, expanding into two new overseas markets thanks to growing demand for its products from ‘skateboard loving paren...

Business Daily Media Business Development

Rishi Sunak's £15 billion cost-of-living package and windfall tax: four experts respond

Rishi Sunak, the UK chancellor of the exchequer, has unveiled a £15 billion package of measures to help households with the cost of living, after energy watchdog Ofgem announced it wou...

Jonquil Lowe, Senior Lecturer in Economics and Personal Finance, The Open University - avatar Jonquil Lowe, Senior Lecturer in Economics and Personal Finance, The Open University

the economic tactics that drive Liverpool and Real Madrid

Liverpool against Real Madrid in the Champions League final is a fixture for football fans to savour – two giants battling it out for one of the most prized trophies in the game. And r...

Simon Chadwick, Global Professor of Sport | Director of Eurasian Sport, EM Lyon - avatar Simon Chadwick, Global Professor of Sport | Director of Eurasian Sport, EM Lyon

Cathay Pacific 2021 Sustainability Report

New commitments in carbon neutrality and diversity, and supporting the Hong Kong community during the pandemicThe Cathay Pacific Group has released its annual Sustainable Development Repor...

Business Daily Media - avatar Business Daily Media

Cozycozy, is tackling consumer manipulation in the travel industry

With its user-centric algorithm, Cozycozy fights against the Online Travel Agencies' rampant manipulation of consumers’ choices. In 2019, 112.3 million domestic trips and 11.3 Million i...

Business Daily Media - avatar Business Daily Media

How to talk to your employer about trauma

Chanintorn.v / ShutterstockThe impact of trauma and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a hidden chronic mental health issue in the workplace. A 2016 survey of UK adults found that one ...

Stefanos Nachmias, Principal Lecturer and Deputy Head of HRM Department, Nottingham Trent University - avatar Stefanos Nachmias, Principal Lecturer and Deputy Head of HRM Department, Nottingham Trent University

Jennifer Westacott's interview with Ross Greenwood

Ross Greenwood, host, Business Now: Joining us is the chief executive of the Business Council of Australia, Jennifer Westacott. Jennifer, many thanks for your time as always. Quite clear...

Ross Greenwood - avatar Ross Greenwood



NewsServices.com

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion