Business Daily Media

there's no retirement on a dead planet

there's no retirement on a dead planet

HESTA, the industry super fund for health and community workers, plans to dump[1] its shares in thermal coal mining companies.

Beyond that, its Net Zero by 2050[2] program announced on Friday commits it to cutting the carbon emissions in its portfolio by one third by 2030, and to “net zero[3]” by 2050.

UniSuper[4], the fund that controls most of the retirement savings in the higher education sector, is bigger, managing A$82.2 billion[5] instead of $53.8 billion.

Like many superfunds, UniSuper does not fully disclose how it invests these funds. However, what it does report (and you can read its report on climate risk and its investments here[6]) is troubling.

It invests 12%[7] of its funds - one in every eight dollars - in companies involved in fossil fuels. Half of that, 6%[8], is invested “directly related to fossil fuel exploration and production business activities.”

6% of UniSuper funds in fossil fuels

UniSuper has responded to criticism of these investments of almost $10 billion and $5 billion by noting that three quarters of its investment portfolio has “set targets around emissions[9]”.

It points to three investment options specifically designed for “members wanting to avoid fossil fuels”. They are Sustainable High Growth, Sustainable Balanced, and Global Environmental Opportunities.

Sustainable High Growth[10] and Sustainable Balanced[11] both include the mining company Rio Tinto in their top 12 shareholdings.

Global Environmental Opportunities[12] excludes Rio but includes companies with no obvious link to environmental opportunities such as the Citrix Systems server and software corporation.

Read more: There's more to super fund HESTA's divestment than ethics[13]

The second-largest holding in that fund (after SolarEdge Technologies Inc[14]) is Digital Realty Trust Inc[15], a data centre provider that sourced 39% of its energy from renewable sources in 2016, but only 30%[16] in 2018.

UniSuper defends these investments by saying it pushes for climate action by engaging with the companies in which it invests. However, its responsible investment reports[17] suggest it voted in favour of few if any climate change-related shareholder resolutions at Australian company meetings.

University staff have fewer choices than most

It would be tempting to suggest that if UniSuper members don’t like UniSuper’s investment choices they can leave.

But UniSuper is unusual among super funds. Most members are tied to it. Enterprise bargains have made membership of UniSuper compulsory for employers of institutions such as the University of Western Australia[18].

Other universities effectively bar employees from choosing other super funds without formal restrictions. UniSuper is the default fund into which new employees are automatically funnelled.

It runs one of Australia’s last remaining defined benefit schemes, in which retirement benefits are related to years of service and salary rather than the accumulation of funds invested, and in which the investment of funds is particularly opaque with regard to climate change.

This is troubling because all new university staff members are defaulted into the defined benefit stream and are unable to switch to the accumulation stream for the first two years[19].

But they’re not powerless

Research suggests consumer action works best when consumers act collectively[20]. UniSuper’s rules make this difficult, but not impossible.

The social media campaign[21] for UniSuper to divest from fossil fuel companies organised by the environment activist group Market Forces[22] has amassed almost 12,000 signatures.

The more that UniSuper members sign up to it, the less room there will be for UniSuper to claim it is serving members interests.

Read more: What limits shareholder activism as a force for good: the free-rider problem[23]

University staff members can approach their UniSuper Consultative Committee[24] about investments, and union members can lobby the National Tertiary Education Union[25] to include more other super funds in enterprise agreements.

And many UniSuper members are actually able to transfer their funds to other super funds (or at partially - it’s harder than for most funds). UniSuper provides a fact sheet[26] explaining how to do it.

Investment decisions matter

The threats posed by climate change to investment returns and standards of living in retirement are real.

The umbrella organisation for the world’s central banks says climate change is likely to cause the largest economic dislocations ever seen[27] and could bring about dramatic drops in the value of portfolios, including a 25%[28] reduction in global GDP growth.

In 2019 the investment advisor Mercer[29] modelled three climate change scenarios; average warming of 2°C, 3°C and 4°C on preindustrial levels, over three time frames - to 2030, 2050, and 2100.

It concluded that 2°C would have the least damaging effect on portfolios, and that fund managers, motivated by the economic and social interest of their beneficiaries, had the opportunity, “arguably the obligation”, to use their investments to help bring about this more economically-secure outcome.

We agree, there is no retirement on a dead planet.


  1. ^ dump (
  2. ^ Net Zero by 2050 (
  3. ^ net zero (
  4. ^ UniSuper (
  5. ^ A$82.2 billion (
  6. ^ here (
  7. ^ 12% (
  8. ^ 6% (
  9. ^ set targets around emissions (
  10. ^ Sustainable High Growth (
  11. ^ Sustainable Balanced (
  12. ^ Global Environmental Opportunities (
  13. ^ There's more to super fund HESTA's divestment than ethics (
  14. ^ SolarEdge Technologies Inc (
  15. ^ Digital Realty Trust Inc (
  16. ^ 30% (
  17. ^ responsible investment reports (
  18. ^ University of Western Australia (
  19. ^ first two years (
  20. ^ collectively (
  21. ^ social media campaign (
  22. ^ Market Forces (
  23. ^ What limits shareholder activism as a force for good: the free-rider problem (
  24. ^ UniSuper Consultative Committee (
  25. ^ National Tertiary Education Union (
  26. ^ fact sheet (
  27. ^ largest economic dislocations ever seen (
  28. ^ 25% (
  29. ^ Mercer (

Authors: Adam Barsky, Associate professor of Management, University of Melbourne

Read more

Business Daily Media Business Development

Turning resolutions into short-term survival and long-term growth tactics

Few Australian industries have been harder hit by the pandemic than hospitality. After two years of lockdowns, social distancing restrictions, staff shortages and supply chain woes, 2022...

Paul Hadida, General Manager, APAC at SevenRooms - avatar Paul Hadida, General Manager, APAC at SevenRooms

The ‘baby bust’ is set to kick-off an AI-boom

The Australian workforce is set to see almost an entire generation retire within the next 15 years. Firstlinks predicts that there will be more baby boomers exiting the workforce than 15-y...

Andy Mellor Regional Vice President of Australia at Kofax. - avatar Andy Mellor Regional Vice President of Australia at Kofax.

How Microsoft's Activision Blizzard takeover will drive metaverse gaming into the mass market

Ready Player 1,000,000,0001?Sergey NivensMicrosoft was positioning itself as one of the pioneers of the metaverse even before its US$75 billion deal to buy online gaming giant Activision Bli...

Theo Tzanidis, Senior Lecturer in Digital Marketing, University of the West of Scotland - avatar Theo Tzanidis, Senior Lecturer in Digital Marketing, University of the West of Scotland

Some of the super-rich want to pay more tax – but society cannot afford to depend on them

Shutterstock/PilgujDemands for the super wealthy to pay more taxes are not new. But they don’t usually come from billionaires or millionaires.Yet on January 19 2022, around 100 of the ...

Peter Bloom, Professor of Management, University of Essex - avatar Peter Bloom, Professor of Management, University of Essex

A killer app for the metaverse? Fill it with AI avatars of ourselves – so we don't need to go there

Ready avatar one?Athitat ShinagowinBig numbers coming. Microsoft’s US$75 billion (£55 billion) acquisition of Activision Blizzard has landed – true to Call of Duty vernacul...

Alex Connock, Fellow at Said Business School, University of Oxford, University of Oxford - avatar Alex Connock, Fellow at Said Business School, University of Oxford, University of Oxford

Labelling Equipment; Prayers Have Been Heard and, Answered

If you are an instrumental part of a management team for a business that now requires labels for their products or goods, then traditionally you’d have had one of three choices, if the...

Business Daily Media - avatar Business Daily Media

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion