Business Daily Media

In the midst of an LNG export boom, why are we getting so little for our gas?

  • Written by Diane Kraal, Senior Lecturer, Business Law and Taxation Dept, Monash Business School, Monash University

So worried is the government about the meagre income it is getting from gas during the middle of Australia’s biggest gas export boom that it asked an independent advisor to chair a review[1] and is getting the treasury[2] to run the ruler over his recommendations.

Australia gets paid for gas mined from under its waters by the “petroleum resource rent tax[3]” set up by the Hawke government in 1988.

But payments peaked at around A$2.5 billion[4] in 2000-01. They are now less than half that, and much lower still as a share of the economy and as a share of gas exported.

The government’s December budget update predicts petroleum resource rent tax revenue of just $1.15 billion[5] this financial year, revised down from the $1.4 billion expected in the May budget.

It has pencilled in only $1.15 billion for each of the next three years.

Qatar, which exports the about the same amount[6] of gas as Australia, is said to have got more than A$20 billion[7] in 2018.

Our tax is good in theory

The weak performance of the petroleum resource rent tax is all the odder because it has been held up as the gold standard for resource taxation.

The 2009 Henry Tax Review wanted to apply the model to iron ore and other minerals, which the Rudd government attempted to, announcing a resource super profit tax[8] in 2010.

The Gillard government cleaved it to what became the milder minerals resource rent tax[9], before it was abolished by the Abbott government in 2014[10].

The petroleum resource rent tax collects a share of the profit made from mining gas instead of charging a fixed royalty of the kind imposed by state governments for other minerals.

But the “profit” depends on the choice of the price at which the gas is “sold” from one part of the entity that mines it to another before it is processed and turned into liquid for export.

It’s not as good in practice

There is a regulated method to calculate the true “transfer price” for the purpose of determining the tax payable. If it produces too low a result (as it seems to have) too little profit will be recorded and too little tax will be charged.

The Turnbull government was concerned enough about what was being charged to set up a petroleum resource rent tax review headed by former treasury official Mike Callighan[11] in 2016.

image The Australian , Saturday February 8, 2020[12] Callahan identified four reasons[13] for dwindling reported profits at a time of record production: declining oil and gas prices, declining production from older projects, the massive expenses involved in setting up new mega projects, and transfers of spending between projects for accounting purposes. He also recommended an examination of the transfer pricing formula. In 2018 Treasurer Josh Frydenberg tightened[14] some of the provisions and asked the treasury to lead a review[15] of the formula that is due to report mid-year. So large are the potential revenue gains that The Australian[16] newspaper has reported that they could keep the budget in surplus. We calculate the price of gas strangely To determine the transfer price at which gas from Commonwealth waters is transferred from the part of the entity that extracts it to the rest of the entity, the Australian government uses a method used nowhere else in the world, and certainly not by Australian states in the calculation of their royalties on minerals. It adopted the method on the recommendation of accounting firm Arthur Anderson[17] in 1998, a few years before it was disgraced in the Enron scandal[18] in the United States and stopped using that name. The method averages two prices – the “net-back” price, which is used elsewhere, and a bespoke “cost-plus price” which is used nowhere else and purports to be a measure of the cost of mining the gas, but which oddly excludes both the cost of exploring for the gas and the cost of the gas itself. Read more: Australia must catch up with Papua New Guinea on how we tax gas[19] The more commonly-used (and usually larger) net-back price is calculated by working backwards from the price at which the product is sold to the end-user, subtracting the costs involved in getting it to that point. Modelling I have conducted for a article co-authored with Machiel Mulder and Peter Perey in the UNSW Law Journal[20] finds that if the net-back price alone was used (as it is elsewhere) the big gas exporters would pay the government A$15.5 billion over the years between now and 2030, instead of the presently-expected $5.5 billion. We shouldn’t value gas at zero There is no obvious reason for the Australian government to value the gas itself at zero. The idea that its only value comes from the equipment, labour and technical know-how used to extract it wouldn’t be accepted in the United States or in any other place that charges for resources extracted and demands payment promptly upon extraction. Fortunately, the government of Queensland continues with royalties for onshore gas and the government of Western Australia continues with royalties for North West Shelf gas. If the treasury’s review of gas transfer pricing results in only fine-tuning the existing regulations it will miss the chance to get us a proper return on our resources. We own them and they are worth something. Australians have a right to be paid what their resources are worth and to use that money to build government services or a budget surplus. Listen to Dr Kraal discuss petroleum resource rent tax at Monash ‘Thought Capital[21]

References

  1. ^ review (treasury.gov.au)
  2. ^ treasury (ministers.treasury.gov.au)
  3. ^ petroleum resource rent tax (www.ato.gov.au)
  4. ^ A$2.5 billion (treasury.gov.au)
  5. ^ $1.15 billion (budget.gov.au)
  6. ^ about the same amount (www.smh.com.au)
  7. ^ more than A$20 billion (www.abc.net.au)
  8. ^ resource super profit tax (www.aph.gov.au)
  9. ^ minerals resource rent tax (www.hawkerbritton.com)
  10. ^ 2014 (www.allens.com.au)
  11. ^ Mike Callighan (treasury.gov.au)
  12. ^ The Australian , Saturday February 8, 2020 (www.theaustralian.com.au)
  13. ^ four reasons (treasury.gov.au)
  14. ^ tightened (treasury.gov.au)
  15. ^ review (treasury.gov.au)
  16. ^ The Australian (www.theaustralian.com.au)
  17. ^ Arthur Anderson (treasury.gov.au)
  18. ^ Enron scandal (en.wikipedia.org)
  19. ^ Australia must catch up with Papua New Guinea on how we tax gas (theconversation.com)
  20. ^ UNSW Law Journal (www.unswlawjournal.unsw.edu.au)
  21. ^ Thought Capital (www2.monash.edu)

Authors: Diane Kraal, Senior Lecturer, Business Law and Taxation Dept, Monash Business School, Monash University

Read more https://theconversation.com/in-the-midst-of-an-lng-export-boom-why-are-we-getting-so-little-for-our-gas-131461

Business Today

1 in 6 US kids are in families below the poverty line

The official child poverty rate is about the same today as in 1967.More Than Words Photography by Alisa Brouwer/Moment Open via Getty ImagesCC BY-NDIn the United States, children are more likely to experience poverty than people o...

Hunt and Brew launches Australia-first cold brew coffee

Australian boutique coffee maker Hunt and Brew has announced it will be sourcing the beans for its new “Australia” cold brew coffee from far north Queensland in a move that will make the company one of the largest buyers of ...

What you need to know about the Defense Production Act – the 1950s law Biden invoked to try to end the baby formula shortage

Biden invoked the Defense Production Act to help end the shortage of baby formula. AP Photo/David J. PhillipU.S. President Joe Biden on May 18, 2022, announced he is invoking the Defense Production Act to help end the shortage of ...

Baby formula industry was primed for disaster long before key factory closed down

Cities are trying to address the baby formula shortage with community drives.AP Photo/David J. PhillipThe conditions that led to a shortage of baby formula were set in motion long before the February 2022 closure of the Similac fa...

Utilising communication tech to alleviate employee burn out

Hybrid work solidified into the business model in 2021 – plain and simple. Jabra research revealed 42 per cent of employees last year requested leadership to help make their virtual workspace more comfortable. Employees are ...

Space Machines readies for liftoff securing launch services deal with SpaceX

SpaceX to carry Space Machines' Optimus Orbital Transfer Vehicle as part of its April 2023 mission. Optimus is one of the largest spacecraft built in Australia and furthers Australia’s sovereign capabilities toward in-space...

Business Daily Media Business Development

the supermarket business model is too fragile to shield customers from rising food prices

Shutterstock/photocriticalFood prices, like almost everything else, are rising fast. There have recently been warnings of “apocalyptic” costs, and a declaration that the “e...

Lisa Jack, Professor of Accounting, University of Portsmouth - avatar Lisa Jack, Professor of Accounting, University of Portsmouth

How soaring inflation can be particularly harmful for young people

Shutterstock/SpeedKingzInflation rates have become almost impossible to ignore. In the UK, inflation has soared in recent months, now reaching 9% – the highest rate for 40 years. The B...

Shampa Roy-Mukherjee, Associate Professor in Economics, University of East London - avatar Shampa Roy-Mukherjee, Associate Professor in Economics, University of East London

it won't control interest rates and inequality will widen

The UK local elections in May saw gains for nationalists in Scotland and Northern Ireland, raising the prospect of increased debates over the future make-up of the country. In Scotland, Firs...

Eoin McLaughlin, Senior Lecturer in Economics, University College Cork - avatar Eoin McLaughlin, Senior Lecturer in Economics, University College Cork

Hunt and Brew launches Australia-first cold brew coffee

Australian boutique coffee maker Hunt and Brew has announced it will be sourcing the beans for its new “Australia” cold brew coffee from far north Queensland in a move that will make t...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

Utilising communication tech to alleviate employee burn out

Hybrid work solidified into the business model in 2021 – plain and simple. Jabra research revealed 42 per cent of employees last year requested leadership to help make their virtual wo...

David Piggott, Managing Director ANZ at Jabra - avatar David Piggott, Managing Director ANZ at Jabra

Space Machines readies for liftoff securing launch services deal with SpaceX

SpaceX to carry Space Machines' Optimus Orbital Transfer Vehicle as part of its April 2023 mission. Optimus is one of the largest spacecraft built in Australia and furthers Australia’...

Business Daily Media - avatar Business Daily Media



NewsServices.com

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion