Business Daily Media

The Times Real Estate

.

'Can-do capitalism' is delivering less than it used to. Here are 3 reasons why

  • Written by Peter Martin, Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University
'Can-do capitalism' is delivering less than it used to. Here are 3 reasons why

The good news is supposed to be that when the government gets out of the way “can-do capitalism” will have us roaring back to where we were before.

That’s the prime minister’s newest slogan[1], and we had better hope for more.

The unpleasant truth is that before the pandemic Australia’s economy was disturbingly and unusually weak. Can-do capitalism wasn’t doing what it should.

Reserve Bank chief economist Luci Ellis[2] put it this way a few days after Morrison talked about freeing the engines of the economy to do their work.

In the decade or so leading up to the pandemic, there was a nagging sense that these engines of prosperity were running out of steam – investment was low, productivity growth was lagging, and many of the behaviours we associate with business dynamism were on the decline.

Outside of mining, business investment had been shrinking as a share of the economy for more than a decade.

Private non-mining business investment, share of nominal GDP

Net of second-hand asset transfers. ABS, RBA[3]

Outside of the ride-share industry, fewer businesses were being created and fewer businesses destroyed.

“For all the talk of disruption, the overall sense one gets from the data is of a bit less dynamism or inclination to shake things up,” Ellis said.

And we were in the middle of a “great resignation[4]” of a different kind to the departures from jobs being seen in the United States.

Australians were increasingly resigned to staying in the jobs they had. Job switching had sunk to all-time lows.

Proportion of employed Australians who switched jobs during the year

Australian Bureau of Statistics[5] In short, despite technological revolutions, despite a government saying it was getting out of the way, and despite record low interest rates that made it cheap to invest and expand, in the lead-up to COVID-19 businesses weren’t doing that. By the time the pandemic arrived, annual economic growth had slid to 2.1%. Government hasn’t been holding business back One thing Ellis says can’t explain the pre-pandemic reluctance of businesses to invest is government regulation pushing up costs. She says if costs had been rising, inflation wouldn’t have fallen to near record lows. And if labour costs had been rising, wage growth wouldn’t have fallen to unprecedented lows, and firms would have been investing more in machines to replace workers. Businesses themselves have been unusually cautious There’s evidence to suggest that in the decade since the global financial crisis Australian (and other) firms have become more risk-averse. Instead of falling with the falling cost of borrowing, the “hurdle[6]” rates of return that businesses tell the Reserve Bank they require in order to justify investments have remained stubbornly high. It’s a “won’t do” rather than a “can do” mindset, and Ellis says it might be because Australian managers don’t want to be associated with projects that fail, or because their firms have only limited management capacities and don’t want to commit to projects in case better ones come along. Except for some firms Her most intriguing suggestion is that some firms are market leaders at installing new technologies (especially those driven by artificial intelligence) – so much so that their competitors can’t catch up. Tip Top cut distribution costs 14%. CSIRO[7] Tip Top Bakeries produces more than one million loaves of bread a day and delivers to more than 18,000 locations Australia-wide. It used to send out its trucks in hub-and-spoke patterns using schedules drawn up by humans. Since it began using artificial intelligence and machine learning to route trucks in configurations no human would have thought of, it has cut its distribution costs 14%[8] and lifted its gross profit after distribution 7%. Ellis makes the point that earlier technological innovations such as laptops and spreadsheets were easy to use. Artificial intelligence and machine learning might be the first new technologies to be actually harder to use and require a rarer set of skills than those they replace. Read more: If you're preparing students for 21st century jobs, you're behind the times[9] The few “superstar” firms that adopt these new technologies (such as Woolworths[10] with its fully automated distribution centre) are becoming able to do things their smaller competitors cannot, locking those lesser firms into a “low-wage, low-investment groove”. Ellis cites evidence that the spread of technological knowledge has slowed, leading to a “winner-takes-all world” of increasing industry concentration. It might still be possible to convince a lender you’ll be Australia’s next big thing in an industry with a market leader, but it’s getting harder. ‘Can-do capitalism’ needs help Reserve Bank Assistant Governor Luci Ellis[11] The third possible explanation advanced by Ellis for the growth of the “think carefully before attempting” mindset over the past decade is in sharp contrast to Morrison’s distinction between “can-do capitalism” and “don’t-do governments”. It’s to do with long-term cycles. When conditions are weak, Ellis says, firms focus on defending what they’ve got instead of pursuing new opportunities. We’ve been in that cycle for a decade, possibly made worse by governments withdrawing support in order to get nearer to balancing their budgets. Now that governments are spending big and abandoning caution to fight the pandemic there’s a chance the cycle will turn. It would be great if she turns out to be right. If she is, it won’t be because the prime minister was right. It’ll be because business needed a leg-up. References^ newest slogan (www.pm.gov.au)^ Luci Ellis (www.rba.gov.au)^ ABS, RBA (www.rba.gov.au)^ great resignation (theconversation.com)^ Australian Bureau of Statistics (www.abs.gov.au)^ hurdle (www.rba.gov.au)^ CSIRO (research.csiro.au)^ 14% (research.csiro.au)^ If you're preparing students for 21st century jobs, you're behind the times (theconversation.com)^ Woolworths (www.woolworthsgroup.com.au)^ Reserve Bank Assistant Governor Luci Ellis (www.rba.gov.au)Authors: Peter Martin, Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University

Read more https://theconversation.com/can-do-capitalism-is-delivering-less-than-it-used-to-here-are-3-reasons-why-172376

Cutting edge AI technology designed for doctors to reduce patient wait times launched in NZ

New Zealand specialist doctors now have access to Artificial Intelligence technology to help reduce patient wait times and experts say it could be...

Launchd Takes Off: Former AFL Stars Lead Tech-Powered Platform Set to Disrupt Talent and Influencer Marketing

Backed by Institutional Capital, Launchd Combines Five Leading Agencies and Smart Technology to Deliver Measurable Results Influencer marketing i...

Meet the Australian fintech unlocking rewards for small businesses

Small businesses make up 98 per cent of all businesses in Australia, yet they continue to bear the brunt of economic uncertainty. According to Credi...

Teleperformance (TP) Business Insights Report Reveals Key Shifts in Consumer Behaviour

TP’s Business Insights report  into consumer behaviors and preferences, taking in more than 57,000 respondents across 19 sectors, is shedding new li...

HubSpot launches platform-wide AI tools to help businesses close the adoption gap

HubSpot today unveiled more than 200 updates across its customer platform to help businesses grow better. The release introduces smarter tools, new AI...

Why Every Leader Needs a Personal Branding Strategy in 2025

One of the best investments you can make in 2025? Your Personal Brand.In today’s competitive and digitally driven business world, authenticity and...

Sell by LayBy