Finding a roofing contractor you can actually trust is one of the bigger decisions any homeowner or commercial property owner has to make. North Jersey doesn't make it easy on roofs either — heavy snow and ice in winter, strong storms rolling through in summer — which is exactly why a durable, professionally installed roof isn't optional here. Price matters, sure, but customer reviews tend to tell you a lot more about workmanship, communication, reliability, and how a company handles things after the job's done.

Below are ten roofing companies serving North Jersey that have built up genuinely strong reputations. Some have years of experience behind them, others have carved out a specialty — but all of them show up consistently in customer feedback. This list is meant as an informational resource, not a ranking, to help property owners get a clearer picture of who's actually out there doing this work in the region.

1. Roofings Matute

Matute Roofing provides roof replacements, repairs, inspections and installations of many types of roofing systems for homes and businesses throughout North Jersey. The company has developed a strong reputation for responsive service and consistent workmanship, supported by more than 450 five-star reviews on its Google Business Profile. From first inspection to the end of the project, customers consistently talk about straightforward communication and attention to detail.

2. Allied Roofing Solutions

Allied Roofing Solutions is a household name all over North Jersey for residential roofing, full roof replacements, skylight installation and gutter work. Many reviewers mention the professional installation crews as well as the company’s project management and scheduling on time. This is a typical selection for major replacement projects, and homeowners tend to laud detailed inspections and clear explanations of their roofing options.

3. American Home Contractors

American Home Contractors has a strong presence in Northern New Jersey, providing roofing, siding, window and gutter services. Reviews often mention knowledgeable staff, well-organised installation crews and projects that actually get completed on schedule. They work with a range of roofing materials, allowing the homeowner a true opportunity to compare options based on durability, appearance and budget, rather than being pushed into one product.

4. Novalis Roofing & Siding

Novalis Roofing & Siding gets consistently positive feedback for residential exterior work — roofing, siding, gutters, all of it. Customers frequently mention careful, professional installation, along with detailed consultations that actually help homeowners understand what condition their roof is in before anyone recommends a repair or replacement.

5. Precision Roofing Inc

For years, Precision Roofing Inc. has been the choice in North Jersey for residential and commercial roofing. They’re known for asphalt shingle work, flat roof systems, leak repairs and preventative maintenance. Reviews often talk about knowledgeable crews, reliable scheduling, and an ability just before address difficult roofing issues caused by ageing materials before damage from storms.

6. Deegan Roofing

Deegan Roofing covers roofing, siding, gutters, and chimney work across Northern New Jersey. Reviewers often bring up how responsive the team is during emergency repairs, and how well they explain what actually needs fixing and why. Customers also note how professional the field crews are and how clean they keep a job site throughout a project.

7. Done Rite Roofing & Gutters

Done Rite Roofing & Gutters handles installation, repairs, gutters, and exterior home improvement more broadly. Customer feedback tends to focus on prompt inspections, fair estimates, and solid workmanship. They're particularly well-regarded for helping homeowners deal with storm damage while keeping communication clear the whole way through.

8. Five Star Roofing

Five Star Roofing is well known for its replacement, repair and maintenance work, and serves homeowners throughout Northern New Jersey. Reviews frequently mention friendly staff, fast scheduling and a good clean-up after the work is done. Customers also love that the team takes time to actually answer questions about materials and what long-term maintenance will look like.

9. Universal Roofing & Contracting

Universal Roofing and Contracting delivers roofing solutions aimed at homes and businesses, including flat roofing, asphalt shingles as well as inspections. Reviews often mention reliability in craftsmanship, careful project planning and follow-up communication that actually happens. They have a proven track record of success with all types of roofing systems and can handle many types of properties throughout the region.

10. RGB Construction

RGB Construction is technically headquartered in South Jersey, but they've completed roofing projects across a much wider stretch of New Jersey and built a strong online reputation doing it. Services include roof replacement, repairs, siding, windows, and gutters. Customers frequently mention knowledgeable staff and organized project management, along with craftsmanship that keeps showing up in the reviews.

What Actually Makes a Roofing Company Well-Reviewed

Online reviews tend to reveal a lot more than just a star rating if you actually read them. The contractors that stay consistently well-reviewed tend to share a similar set of traits, no matter their size or specialty.

A few things that keep showing up:

• Honest, accurate inspections instead of upsell tactics
• Clear communication before, during, and after the work
• Professional crews that keep a safe job site
• Materials actually suited to local weather, not just whatever's cheapest
• Scheduling that holds up and projects that finish on time
• Thorough cleanup once the work is done
• Warranty support that's actually responsive when something comes up

Patterns across hundreds of reviews tend to say a lot more than any single glowing (or bad) comment — consistency is really the thing worth paying attention to.

What to Check Before Hiring a Roofer

Reviews are genuinely useful, but they shouldn't be the only thing guiding the decision. It's worth verifying licensing, insurance, manufacturer certifications, and actual experience with whatever roofing system the job calls for. Getting a few written estimates also helps compare the actual scope of work, not just the bottom-line price.

Roofers who do a thorough inspection and actually explain what they found tend to help homeowners make better-informed decisions overall. Whether it's a small leak or a full roof replacement on the table, understanding the material options and what maintenance will look like down the road makes a real difference in how things hold up long-term.

Conclusion

North Jersey homeowners and commercial property managers have no shortage of reputable roofing companies to choose from, and each one on this list has built its reputation through real experience and consistent service across the region. Pair solid reviews with a bit of your own due diligence on qualifications, and it gets a lot easier to land on a roofer who actually fits your project — and protects one of the most important investments tied to your property.