Business Daily Media

The big four accounting firms struggle to shake their sexist pasts

  • Written by Ian Gow, Professor and Director of Melbourne Centre for Corporate Governance and Regulation, University of Melbourne
The big four accounting firms struggle to shake their sexist pasts

In many ways, the big four accounting firms – Deloitte, Ernst & Young, KPMG and PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) – have influenced how we work, how we manage, how we invest and how we are governed.

Apart from their staff, the brands themselves are the big firms’ most valuable assets. The value of those brands is grounded in the firms’ histories. But looking into their past reveals many stories of discrimination that the firms may have to face up to to re-brand their future.

Globally, the firms dominate key markets for accounting, tax and audit services. Nearly all the largest businesses in the United States and the United Kingdom, for example, are audited by one or more of the firms.

In 2016 their total revenue exceeded US$130 billion[1]. With almost one million staff[2], the firms are collectively one of the world’s top employers. The number of people who have worked for a big four auditing firm at some point in their career is much larger still.

Today, however, the auditors are facing challenges to their power from technology[3] and regulators[4]. But perhaps the most gravest challenge is cultural.

A chequered past

All four firms trace their history back to 19th century England. In the firms’ earliest incarnations, their partners and staff were all male.

As the firms spread out across the globe, they retained their overwhelming maleness. As late as 1940, for example, only 175 of the 16,000 certified public accountants in the United States were women[5].

Strong forces in society kept things that way. Colleges and universities discouraged women from majoring in accounting. If a woman did graduate with an accounting qualification, she found it difficult to find a position in a major firm.

Arthur Andersen, a firm founded by a former Price Waterhouse partner, waited till 1965 before hiring female accountants. Those accountants were mostly confined to junior and administrative roles – comptometrists, ledger-posting clerks – and they had to leave when they married[6].

At professional gatherings, men opined gravely on the question of women, and what they might be able to do[7]. The opinions awkwardly foreshadowed today’s conversations about digital automation. What accountants said then about women, they say now about robots.

The accounting monoculture’s defining features included blokey, locker-room humour, a competitive, hothouse atmosphere, and a staff induction process that has been likened to brainwashing[8].

When inevitably the monoculture began to wane, the clash with modern ideas was ferocious, and often appalling.

In 1990, for example, Ann B. Hopkins of Price Waterhouse alleged she’d been denied promotion to the partnership on grounds of sexual discrimination. A US judge[9] ordered the firm to offer Hopkins a partnership, and around US$400,000 in back pay.

In 2008, former PwC partner Christina Rich received a significant settlement after a series of alleged incidents that included male partners talking about her breasts. The boys club culture had allegedly thwarted her progression at the firm. In 2014, Erik Pietzka won a discrimination case[10] against PwC on the grounds that his requests to work part-time for family reasons had damaged his prospects for promotion.

Are they really progressing?

In light of this history, the big four in Australia have recently adopted proactive policies that promote equality, diversity and flexibility. Examples include Deloitte’s GLOBE leadership forum[11] and Inspiring Women strategy, aimed at getting an “unfair share of female talent[12]”.

Yet there is a real risk that these policies will not lead to the substantive culture shift that the firms need. The continued emergence of sorry episodes[13] suggests that more work is needed.

The dilemma for the firms’ leaders is this: How to retain the best of their histories while renouncing the prejudices and behaviours that defined the old monoculture? How best to embrace change without dumping much of what defined the firms for so many years?

Beyond further strengthening policies and standards, the firms are becoming more nuanced in the stories they tell about themselves and their past. That past, though, includes an abundance of horrors and blunders.

Sooner or later, the firms will have to fully reckon with their past. When that moment comes, the firms might have to let go of a good deal of their history, their culture, their structure and even their brands.

This piece was jointly written with Stuart Kells.

Professor Ian Gow and Dr Stuart Kells are the authors of The Big Four: The Curious History and Perilous Future of the Global Accounting Monopoly[14].

References

  1. ^ US$130 billion (economia.icaew.com)
  2. ^ almost one million staff (www.statista.com)
  3. ^ technology (www.icaew.com)
  4. ^ regulators (www.ft.com)
  5. ^ were women (www.thebhc.org)
  6. ^ had to leave when they married (www.sciencedirect.com)
  7. ^ what they might be able to do (www.thebhc.org)
  8. ^ likened to brainwashing (www.amazon.com)
  9. ^ US judge (supreme.justia.com)
  10. ^ won a discrimination case (www.telegraph.co.uk)
  11. ^ GLOBE leadership forum (www2.deloitte.com)
  12. ^ unfair share of female talent (www2.deloitte.com)
  13. ^ sorry episodes (www.wsj.com)
  14. ^ The Big Four: The Curious History and Perilous Future of the Global Accounting Monopoly (www.blackincbooks.com.au)

Authors: Ian Gow, Professor and Director of Melbourne Centre for Corporate Governance and Regulation, University of Melbourne

Read more http://theconversation.com/the-big-four-accounting-firms-struggle-to-shake-their-sexist-pasts-95223

Business Today

Cathay Pacific 2021 Sustainability Report

New commitments in carbon neutrality and diversity, and supporting the Hong Kong community during the pandemicThe Cathay Pacific Group has released its annual Sustainable Development Report that addresses its commitment and prog...

Cozycozy, is tackling consumer manipulation in the travel industry

With its user-centric algorithm, Cozycozy fights against the Online Travel Agencies' rampant manipulation of consumers’ choices. In 2019, 112.3 million domestic trips and 11.3 Million international trips were taken by Austral...

Foreign companies exiting Russia echo the pressure campaign against South Africa's racist apartheid system

McDonald's is leaving Russia after three decades of operating there.Sefa Karacan/Anadolu Agency via Getty ImagesMcDonald’s provided many Russians with their first taste of capitalism three decades ago. Now, the global fast-f...

Jennifer Westacott's interview with Ross Greenwood

Ross Greenwood, host, Business Now: Joining us is the chief executive of the Business Council of Australia, Jennifer Westacott. Jennifer, many thanks for your time as always. Quite clearly the government is setting out its age...

Business success as Aussie kids skateboard brand, Ookkie, launches in UK and Europe

Australia’s leading kids skateboard company, Ookkie, has set the wheels in motion for global business success, expanding into two new overseas markets thanks to growing demand for its products from ‘skateboard loving paren...

How a sustainability index can keep Exxon but drop Tesla – and 3 ways to fix ESG ratings to meet investors' expectations

Tesla CEO Elon Musk, shown at an electric vehicle factory, called ESG ratings 'a scam' after an index dropped Tesla. Maja Hitij/Getty ImagesA major stock index that tracks sustainable investments dropped electric vehicle-maker Tes...

Business Daily Media Business Development

Cathay Pacific 2021 Sustainability Report

New commitments in carbon neutrality and diversity, and supporting the Hong Kong community during the pandemicThe Cathay Pacific Group has released its annual Sustainable Development Repor...

Business Daily Media - avatar Business Daily Media

Cozycozy, is tackling consumer manipulation in the travel industry

With its user-centric algorithm, Cozycozy fights against the Online Travel Agencies' rampant manipulation of consumers’ choices. In 2019, 112.3 million domestic trips and 11.3 Million i...

Business Daily Media - avatar Business Daily Media

How to talk to your employer about trauma

Chanintorn.v / ShutterstockThe impact of trauma and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a hidden chronic mental health issue in the workplace. A 2016 survey of UK adults found that one ...

Stefanos Nachmias, Principal Lecturer and Deputy Head of HRM Department, Nottingham Trent University - avatar Stefanos Nachmias, Principal Lecturer and Deputy Head of HRM Department, Nottingham Trent University

Jennifer Westacott's interview with Ross Greenwood

Ross Greenwood, host, Business Now: Joining us is the chief executive of the Business Council of Australia, Jennifer Westacott. Jennifer, many thanks for your time as always. Quite clear...

Ross Greenwood - avatar Ross Greenwood

Business success as Aussie kids skateboard brand, Ookkie, launches in UK and Europe

Australia’s leading kids skateboard company, Ookkie, has set the wheels in motion for global business success, expanding into two new overseas markets thanks to growing demand for its ...

Business Daily Media - avatar Business Daily Media

world's biggest port is returning to normal, but supply chains will get worse before they get better

Shanghai is slowly emerging from a gruelling COVID lockdown that has all but immobilised the city since March. Although Shanghai’s port, which handles one-fifth of China’s shippi...

Sarah Schiffling, Senior Lecturer in Supply Chain Management, Liverpool John Moores University - avatar Sarah Schiffling, Senior Lecturer in Supply Chain Management, Liverpool John Moores University



NewsServices.com

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion