Business Daily Media

How Sydney's Barangaroo tower paved the way for a culture of closed-door deals

  • Written by Dallas Rogers, School of Architecture, Design and Planning, University of Sydney

Crown Towers Sydney, at 75 storeys, is now the city’s tallest building. It should not exist, and certainly not where it is – in prime location on Sydney’s famous harbour.

The redevelopment of the 22-hectare Barangaroo precinct was supposed to transform the former docklands into a world-class example of architectural and public domain design.

But giving Crown Resorts the go-ahead to build its skyscraper – containing a casino, hotel and luxury apartments – diminished the space set aside for parkland in the original concept plan[1] and broke height limits.

This week the ABC’s Four Corners[2] program shed light on how the tower got approved, beginning with a 2012 lunch facilitated by radio celebrity Alan Jones between Crown Resorts’ majority shareholder James Packer and then NSW premier Barry O'Farrell.

It is a familiar story of a culture of wealthy mates and backroom deals. It is also a story about the novel use of an obscure infrastructure approvals mechanism called “unsolicited proposals” – or USPs for short – that circumvented established processes intended to protect the public interest.

The Barangaroo tower has not just changed Sydney’s skyline. It has changed the whole planning system.

An unsolicited proposal

How Sydney's Barangaroo tower paved the way for a culture of closed-door deals James Packer with an artist’s impression of his Crown Casino Barangaroo development proposal at a business function at the Sydney Opera House, May 16 2013. Dean Lewins/AAP

As the Four Corners program related, in February 2012 Packer (one of Australia’s ten wealthiest individuals) asked his friend Jones to organise a meeting with O’Farrell.

In Jones’ penthouse suite overlooking Sydney’s Circular Quay, they ate pies and mash[3] while Packer outlined his vision for a A$1 billion-plus hotel, casino and entertainment complex.

How did Packer’s plan fit into the concept that won Hill Thalis Architecture[4] the international design competition for Barangaroo? It didn’t.

O'Farrell, Jones said[5], pointed to the rigours of NSW’s urban planning process as a barrier to Packer’s idea. The premier “made the point that it wouldn’t be all that easy, but he embraced the vision”.

Packer went public with his vision shortly after. Many objected. Then:

With Packer’s project still facing significant opposition, Premier Barry O’Farrell came up with a novel solution which he proposed at another private meeting in his office. The solution was to use an obscure government policy called the “unsolicited proposals” process.

How unsolicited proposals work

The Productivity Commission has defined[6] an unsolicited proposal as a public-private infrastructure project initiated by a private party, not in response to a request from government.

Common to all guidelines for considering such a proposal is “a requirement for uniqueness or innovation” – with uniqueness implying no other party could reasonably deliver the project for the same value for money in the same time.

But as Serena Lillywhite[7] of Transparency International Australia told Four Corners: “If it’s a project that is considered to be unique and on such a large scale, then it should be going to an open tender process.”

How Sydney's Barangaroo tower paved the way for a culture of closed-door deals The Barangaroo development as seen from the west. Instead of more parkland for locals, a casino and hotel meant for wealthy tourists. /Dan Himbrechts/AAP

Part of the urban planning landscape

We’ve studied unsolicited proposals as part of our research[8] into how planning systems have changed since the 1990s and the implications for public participation and social justice. We’ve been involved in several studies in Sydney’s Millers Point[9] and Barangaroo[10] since 2014.

This research has included interviewing key actors in local and state government, urban planning and heritage professionals, public housing residents facing eviction, journalists, documentary makers and Indigenous knowledge holders.

Since the process was adopted to greenlight Packer’s plan for Barangaroo, unsolicited proposals have become a well-used tool to circumvent the standard approval processes for urban planning in Australia.

The concept has spread to Victoria and Western Australia, where they are called “market-led proposals[11]”, and Queensland[12], where they are also known as “exclusive mandates”.

Read more: Market-led infrastructure may sound good but not if it short-changes the public[13]

Examples include Macquarie Group’s Metro station and towers on Sydney’s Martin Place[14], the redevelopment[15] of Henry Deane Plaza (near Sydney’s central station) by property manager Dexus and Frasers Property Australia, and Transurban’s Northconnex[16] tollway in Sydney, Logan Enhancement Project[17] in Queensland and West Gate Tunnel[18] in Melbourne.

The concept is also spreading internationally[19] as a means to connect global money to local infrastructure projects.

How Sydney's Barangaroo tower paved the way for a culture of closed-door deals Prime Minister Scott Morrison and NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian use the NorthConnex tunnel for a photo opportunity in June 2020. Joel Carrett/AAP

Creating a black box

One bureaucrat who has worked on unsolicited proposals described the process to us. After the initial proposal is made, discussions go on behind closed doors and “some sort of contribution is cooked up”.

Contributions could include a commitment to provide infrastructure or a fee to government by the proponent.

For example, Macquarie Group will “deliver the new metro station, retail space, and pedestrian connections” at Martin Place[20] in exchange for approval to build its towers.

In the case of Crown Resorts’ Barangaroo deal, the promised contributions included guaranteed future taxation revenue and “an upfront licence fee of $100 million[21]” for the state government.

We are not suggesting these negotiations and contributions are corrupt. From a transparency perspective, however, they are concerning. The public does not know the exact nature of the relationships involved, nor the financial details of what (in the words of our bureaucrat) is being “cooked up” and whether they are value for money.

These negotiations happen, as another insider put it, “in a very black box […] no one knows what happens there”.

Baked into the system

Urban planning academics[22] and multiple agencies with oversight on public finances and integrity have flagged this as problematic.

In 2016 the Audit Office of NSW urged greater transparency and public reporting[23] of unsolicited proposals, warning they “pose a greater risk to value for money than procurements done through open, competitive and transparent processes”.

In 2018, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission criticised state governments[24] for accepting unsolicited proposals for tollways, warning the lack of competitive tender processes would inflate costs for taxpayers.

The Victorian Auditor-General made similar warnings in 2019[25].

The Barangaroo casino has yet to open, as NSW’s Independent Liquor and Gaming Authority ponders if Crown Resorts (also being scrutinised by royal commissions in Victoria and Western Australia) is fit to hold a gaming licence.

Read more: It's hard to see how Crown Resorts can be found 'fit and proper' to run Sydney's Barangaroo casino[26]

As Shaun Carter[27], former NSW president of the Australian Institute of Architects, told Four Corners: “We should look at that building and forever know that we should never let that happen again.”

But with unsolicited proposals being baked into the system, the likelihood is that it will happen – again and again.

References

  1. ^ concept plan (www.hillthalis.com.au)
  2. ^ Four Corners (www.abc.net.au)
  3. ^ ate pies and mash (www.abc.net.au)
  4. ^ Hill Thalis Architecture (www.hillthalis.com.au)
  5. ^ Jones said (www.abc.net.au)
  6. ^ has defined (www.pc.gov.au)
  7. ^ as Serena Lillywhite (www.abc.net.au)
  8. ^ our research (doi.org)
  9. ^ Millers Point (doi.org)
  10. ^ Barangaroo (doi.org)
  11. ^ market-led proposals (www.dtf.vic.gov.au)
  12. ^ Queensland (www.parliament.nsw.gov.au)
  13. ^ Market-led infrastructure may sound good but not if it short-changes the public (theconversation.com)
  14. ^ Metro station and towers on Sydney’s Martin Place (www.nsw.gov.au)
  15. ^ redevelopment (www.theurbandeveloper.com)
  16. ^ Northconnex (www.nsw.gov.au)
  17. ^ Logan Enhancement Project (www.transurban.com)
  18. ^ West Gate Tunnel (www.transurban.com)
  19. ^ is also spreading internationally (doi.org)
  20. ^ at Martin Place (www.nsw.gov.au)
  21. ^ licence fee of $100 million (web.archive.org)
  22. ^ Urban planning academics (theconversation.com)
  23. ^ urged greater transparency and public reporting (www.audit.nsw.gov.au)
  24. ^ criticised state governments (www.accc.gov.au)
  25. ^ in 2019 (www.audit.vic.gov.au)
  26. ^ It's hard to see how Crown Resorts can be found 'fit and proper' to run Sydney's Barangaroo casino (theconversation.com)
  27. ^ As Shaun Carter (www.abc.net.au)

Authors: Dallas Rogers, School of Architecture, Design and Planning, University of Sydney

Read more https://theconversation.com/how-sydneys-barangaroo-tower-paved-the-way-for-a-culture-of-closed-door-deals-161816

Business Reports

Businesses encouraged to seek help to deal with cashflow issues

Daniel Riley, leading finance expert and CEO of one of the country’s top business finance providers, Earlypay, is encouraging businesses to reach out for assistance to deal with cashflow issues before it’s too late. “Ou...

Basic Dropshipping Business Tips To Remember

During the pandemic one of the businesses which many people looked to get involved with was dropshipping, a great option if you know what you are doing. This is a business which sees you focus on selling online, contacting manuf...

Aussies plan to turn their side hustle into their full time gig

SIDE HUSTLE BOOM: 4 IN 5 AUSSIES TURN SIDE HUSTLE DREAMS INTO DOLLARS    New research reveals more than three quarters (78%) of Aussies plan to turn their side hustle into their full time gig   With the rise in cost of ...

Fixing Broken Processes in the Financial Services Sector

As established financial services firms face increasing competition with the emergence of nimble fintech rivals, many are looking for ways to make their internal processes more efficient. Manual, paper-based workflows and proce...

Six ways businesses can minimise travel disruptions

While business travel continues to grow healthily, travellers may have another potential disruption to be on guard for: the rapid rise of flu and COVID cases that are expected to peak in the coming months. A leading travel manag...

How Australians are missing out on retirement returns

Australians are missing out on potential returns by not regularly salary sacrificing, according to new research by Finder, Australia’s most visited comparison site. A new Finder survey of 722 people with super revealed only...

Web Busters - Break into local search

WebBusters.com.au